Boeing 717-200 vs. Boeing 737 MAX 8

The Boeing 717-200 is a narrow-body, twin-engine jetliner designed for regional and short to medium-haul routes. Characterized by its efficiency and operational flexibility, it caters to airlines requiring a reliable and cost-effective solution for less dense routes. Developed as a part of the Boeing family, the 717-200 first entered service in 1998, marking Boeing's entry into the regional jet market. It was produced until 2006, with a focus on meeting the specific demands of regional air travel. The aircraft's production history reflects Boeing's strategy to offer a range of jetliners tailored to various market segments.

With dimensions of 37.8 meters (124.0 feet) in length and a wingspan of 28.5 meters (93.3 feet), the 717-200 is ideally sized for operations at smaller airports. It typically accommodates 110 passengers, providing a comfortable and efficient travel experience on regional journeys. Powered by two rear-mounted Rolls-Royce BR715 engines, the Boeing 717-200 delivers a total thrust of 190.0 kN (42,800 lbf). Its fuel capacity of 16,670 liters (4,404 US gallons) supports a range of 3,815 kilometers (2,060 nautical miles), making it suitable for various regional routes. The aircraft has a cruise speed of 822 km/h (511 mph).

In the competitive regional jet market, the Boeing 717-200 stands as a contender against models like the Bombardier CRJ Series and Embraer E-Jets. Its introduction provided airlines with a practical and economical option for regional networks, balancing the needs for capacity, range, and cost-efficiency. Airlines such as Delta Air Lines, Hawaiian Airlines, and QantasLink have utilized the 717-200 for its operational efficiency and adaptability. Not many 717s are still in service today. Delta is one of the last airlines to be phasing out its own fleet.

The Boeing 717-200's legacy in commercial aviation is defined by its role in regional air travel. While its production has concluded, the 717-200 continues to be recognized for its contribution to the regional aviation segment.

The Boeing 737 MAX 8 is a narrow-body, twin-jet aircraft, and the upgraded version of the Boeing 737-800 from the NG family. As of 2023, over 1100 737 MAX jets are in service, with the majority of them being MAX 8s. The very first MAX 8 was delivered to Malindo Air in May of 2017. The state-of-the-art jet offers airlines a modern and versatile option for short to medium-haul routes.

A 20-month grounding interrupted deliveries after two fatal crashes traced to the programming of the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System (MCAS). Now restored with multiple software fixes and training revisions, the 737 MAX series retains strong market demand for economical medium haul flight connectivity globally.

With a length of 129.7 feet (39.5 meters) and a wingspan of 117.8 feet (35.9 meters), the 737 MAX 8 is adept at accommodating the operational needs of both large international airports and smaller regional terminals. It is designed to seat up to 178 passengers, striking a balance between capacity and passenger comfort. The aircraft is powered by two CFM International LEAP-1B engines, each capable of producing 29,300 lbf of thrust (130.0 kN), totaling 58,600 lbf (260.0 kN). This power, combined with a fuel capacity of 6,816 US gallons (25,800 liters), enables the 737 MAX 8 to cover a range of 3,548 nautical miles (6,570 kilometers). The upgraded LEAP-1B turbofans contribute 20% fuel savings thanks to lighter composite designs. Re-engineered tail sections and wing tips further boost efficiency.

The 737 MAX 8 is rivaled by the Airbus A320neo. These two are arguably the most capable and efficient airliners for the modern medium haul market. The airlines with the most MAX 8s include Southwest Airlines, American Airlines, United Airlines. Other carriers include Flydubai, Aeromexico, Air Canada, and TUI Group. With future rate increases slated as demand persists, the MAX 8 remains well-positioned as sub 180-seat workhorse growing the 737 legacy.