ATR 72-600 vs. Embraer E190

The ATR 72-600, part of the renowned ATR aircraft family, is a twin-engine, high-wing turboprop airliner designed primarily for regional and short-haul flights. First flown in 1988, this model has become a popular choice for airlines operating in small markets.

ATR, the manufacturer of the ATR 72, has produced over 1800 units through 2023. The -600 variant is the latest model to be designed, making its first flight in 2007. Compared to the smaller ATR 42, the ATR 72 has a longer fuselage and wider wingspan. At 27.2 meters (89.1 feet) from nose to tail and a width of 27.1 meters (88.7 feet), the ATR 72-600 is characterized by its compact and efficient design, suitable for operations at smaller airports. It has a max takeoff weight of 23,000 kg (50,706 lbs), and a max payload of 7,400 kg (16,313 lbs). The ATR 72-600 is powered by two engines, delivering a total output of 3692 kW (4,950 shp), providing reliable performance for its operational requirements. It has a fuel capacity of 6,400 liters (1,691 US gallons), which contributes to its range of 1,528 kilometers (825 nautical miles). With a cruise speed of 510 km/h (317 mph), the ATR 72-600 offers an efficient travel option for regional airlines, connecting smaller communities and cities.

In the regional aviation sector, the ATR 72-600 competes with aircraft like the Bombardier Q400 and Embraer E-Jets. Its advantage lies in its operational cost-effectiveness, making it an appealing choice for airlines serving regional routes with moderate passenger volumes. Airlines such as Air New Zealand, IndiGo, SAS, and TAROM operate the ATR 72-600, utilizing its capabilities to serve regional networks. These carriers value the aircraft for its ability to provide efficient, reliable service on shorter routes, which are crucial for maintaining regional connectivity. The introduction of the ATR 72-600 to the market was driven by the need for an economical, versatile aircraft that could effectively serve the regional aviation segment. Its operational role has been defined by its capacity to offer cost-efficient solutions for airlines operating on less dense routes.

Today, the ATR 72-600 remains a significant player in the regional aircraft market, demonstrating its continued relevance in connecting smaller cities and communities.

Introduced in 2004, the Embraer E190 is a larger member of the E-Jet family, offering expanded capabilities for regional airlines. As a narrow-body regional jet, the E190 addresses a unique segment of the market, combining increased passenger capacity with the operational flexibility required for regional routes.

At 36.3 meters (118.9 feet) in length, the E190 stands as one of the bigger variants within the E-Jet family. This additional length not only provides more cabin space but also enhances the aircraft's payload and range capabilities. The E190 is equipped with GE engines that offer a combined thrust of 178.0 kN (40,000 lbf). Additionaly, its MTOW of 51,800 kg (114,199 lb) is significantly more than that of the E170/175. With a range of approximately 4,537 kilometers (2,450 nautical miles), the E190 is adept at connecting regional destinations with the efficiency and speed required in modern air travel.

The E190's cabin can comfortably accommodate 100 passengers in a standard configuration, scaling up to 114 passengers in a denser layout. The interior design of the E190 emphasizes passenger comfort, integrating features such as advanced climate control, ergonomic seating, and modern in-flight entertainment options. These elements collectively ensure a pleasant and relaxing journey for passengers, even on longer regional trips.

In its market segment, the Embraer E190 offers a balance of efficiency and capacity that competes with other regional jets and smaller mainline aircraft. Its operational profile makes it a compelling choice for airlines looking to bridge the gap between traditional regional jets and larger single-aisle aircraft. Airlines such as JetBlue (launch customer), KLM Cityhopper, Air Canada, and Georgian Airways have integrated the E190 into their fleets. The aircraft enables these airlines to serve a diverse array of routes, from high-density short-haul sectors to less frequented longer regional routes. In 2018, early production E190s were valued at less than $10 million, while the newer units were worth about $30 million.

The Embraer E190 represents a significant advancement in the regional jet category, offering airlines an aircraft that extends the boundaries of traditional regional aviation. Its combination of enhanced capacity, range, and passenger-focused features make it a valuable asset for airlines seeking to optimize their regional operations while providing high levels of passenger satisfaction.