Boeing 737-600 vs. Bombardier Q400 (Dash 8)

Launched in 1998, the Boeing 737-600 is the smallest aircraft in the 737 Next Generation (NG) series. It succeeded the 737-500, and was a significant evolution in Boeing's narrow-body offerings. It featured many upgraded features from the previous 737s, including aerodynamics, engines, and avionics. As the smallest NG variant, the 737-600 was designed for efficiency and adaptability, catering to airlines requiring a compact jet for short to medium-haul routes.

This aircraft extends 102.4 feet (31.2 meters) in length with a wingspan of 112.6 feet (34.3 meters). The 737-600, with a typical seating capacity for 123 passengers, offers an ideal balance between passenger comfort and efficiency, making it a fitting choice for airlines serving routes with moderate passenger demand. Equipped with two CFM International CFM56-7B20 engines, the 737-600 has a total thrust of 45,400 lbf (202.0 kN). This engine power, coupled with a fuel capacity of 6,868 US gallons (26,000 liters), gives the -600 a range of 3,051 nautical miles (5,650 kilometers). The 737-600 has a cruise speed of 528 mph (850 km/h) enabling airlines to maintain efficient and swift operations, particularly beneficial for regional network connections.

In the late 1990s and early 2000s, the Boeing 737-600 competed with aircraft such as the Airbus A318 and Bombardier CRJ series, offering airlines a modern alternative in the narrow-body market. Airlines including Scandinavian Airlines (SAS), Westjet, and Air Algerie operated the Boeing 737-600. Ultimately, the -600 variant was not a popular model of the 737 due to its economics. The -700, only slightly heavier, had a much greater payload. Additionally, the larger market was moving more towards higher capacity narrow-bodies with lower unit costs and greater revenue opportunities.

The Bombardier Q400, belonging to the DHC Dash 8 series, is a turboprop aircraft engineered for regional aviation. With a length of 32.9 meters (107.9 feet) and a wingspan of 28.4 meters (93.2 feet), the Q400 is designed to operate efficiently in diverse regional airport environments. It strives in operations that require agility and short takeoff and landing capabilities. From the outside, the Q400 can be identified by its high-wing design, 6-bladed propellors, T-tail, and wing-mounted landing gears. The Q400 was the most popular variant of the Dash 8, with over 600 delivered as of September 2019. De Havilland ultimately paused Dash 8-Q400 production in 2021 due to the pandemic and lack of demand.

Powered by two Pratt & Whitney PW150A engines, the aircraft is capable of producing a substantial power output, . This power enables the Q400 to achieve a range of approximately 2,040 kilometers (1,102 nautical miles), making it a suitable choice for various regional routes, from short hops to more extended connections. The selection of turboprop engines for the Q400 reflects a focus on fuel efficiency and operational cost-effectiveness, key considerations in the regional airline market. The cabin of the Q400, configured to seat about 76 passengers in a standard layout, can be adapted to accommodate up to 90 passengers in high-density seating arrangements. This flexibility allows airlines to optimize the aircraft for different route profiles. The cabin design incorporates elements aimed at improving passenger comfort, such as noise reduction, which is particularly beneficial during the shorter flights typical in regional travel.

In the regional aircraft market, the Bombardier Q400 offers an alternative to similar capacity regional jets, like the ATR 72. The aircraft's competitive edge lies in its combination of turboprop efficiency with a passenger capacity that approaches that of larger regional jets. This balance makes the Q400 a viable option for airlines operating a range of regional routes. Operators of the Q400, including Porter Airlines, Flybe, and Horizon Air, have found the aircraft suitable for their diverse regional networks. The Q400's operational profile allows these airlines to service routes efficiently, connecting smaller cities and towns with major hubs. The aircraft's role in these fleets underscores its suitability for the specific demands of regional air travel, where efficiency, versatility, and cost-effectiveness are paramount.

In summary, the Bombardier Q400's introduction into the regional aviation sector provided airlines with an aircraft that aligns well with the operational requirements of short to medium-haul routes. Its design, capacity, and range capabilities make it a noteworthy choice for airlines looking to enhance their regional operations.